Clan Community Shield

I think that for line infantry need make exception in rule 4 max same because almost all factions have only one type lines (only Netherlands have 3 type lines, USA have simple lines and us marines and Maratha have two type lines) and guards have too high cost.

If make limit for light dragoons then whether it will be entered in the first round? Or we will play in first round with rules no fixed art and max 4 same only?

I think that dragoons needs max 2 for balance.

hi,

My suggest is to forbidden the art bug with shrapnell. Guys must shoot on the art range!!!!

Sylquartz you know as well as anybody here that this is a rule that simply cannot be reinforced or proven. Shrapnel and cannons as a whole, by their very nature, particularly in this era, were wildly inaccurate in terms of the distance they travelled. Ergo, certain teams will certainly be feigning ignorance when it comes to this e.g "Oh, well it overshot but I didn't mean for it to do it..." - try telling that to my 20 dead men kind sir!

But yeah, it's better to just have it and that way both sides can use it, thus it is even.

And what about dragoons spam ? 4 dragoons is very much. I thinks needs rule 3 HA max including 2 light dragoons max.

My suggestion is that for a tourney that is being used as a trial for some rules for a league this one is moving at a snails pace.

Might I suggest some stricter rules around posting and a longer deadline around playing the games. A 1 week deadline really is setting itself up to fail and makes the extension of deadlines seem arbitrary when the admin is almost obliged to extend at least once. Even if these kind of rulings aren't introduced in this tourney I still think it warrants discussion. How can we best ensure that a tourney ticks along at a decent pace. Because personally I really can't be bothered with a tourney that pretty much guarantees I'll spend more time waiting around for players than actually playing the game. I'd be happier playing inter clan friendly matches. I hope I'm not alone in this.